Most of the audiobooks on this list aren’t horror, but psychological fiction that gets into your brain and stays there for a while. If I’ve written a review, the link will take you to it (in a new window or tab). Clicking the cover images at the bottom should take you to the publisher’s info.
The Dinner by Hans Koch, translated by Sam Garret, narrated by Clive Mantle
Horns by Joe Hill, narrated by Fred Berman
The Marbury Lens by Andrew Smith, narrated by Mark Boyett
The Night Strangers by Chris Bohjalian, narrated by Mark Bramhall and Alison Fraser
The Night Swimmer by Matt Bondurant, narrated by Hillary Huber
The Other Typist by Suzanne Rindell, narrated by Gretchen Mol
The Reapers Are the Angels by Alden Bell, narrated by Tai Simmons
The Shining by Stephen King, narrated by Campbell Scott
(follow this up with Doctor Sleep by Stephen King, the sequel narrated by Will Patton)
What creepy/haunting audiobooks should I add to this list? Please let me know in the comments!