Glass Houses by Louise Penny is #13 in the Armand Gamache series, and the books have become enormously popular. I’d like to think I was an early adopter, but #1 came out in 2006, and I can’t say for sure I’ve been pushing these books for 11 years!
If you haven’t heard of Louise Penny, you must not avoid anything that even remotely resembles crime fiction. She was even on CBS Morning America last month:
https://www.cbsnews.com/videos/louise-penny-on-her-new-inspector-gamache-novel-glass-houses/
Glass Houses might be a hard one to jump into the series with, because the series is so far along, but I think the book succeeds both as a stand-alone title and in moving the characters forward in the series. The author does very well bringing in enough backstory for new readers (or to remind regular readers of the series) to grasp the personalities and motivations of the main characters and the essential peacefulness of the village of Three Pines, which manages to remain undisturbed despite the disturbing number of violent murders that happen there!
In an interview recorded with the audiobooks’ new narrator, Robert Bathurst, at the end of Glass Houses, Louise Penny says her books aren’t crime fiction. With the main character the Chief Superintendent of the Sûreté du Québec, the police department for the whole of the province, and with a murder mystery at the center of just about every book, it seems like plain old genre prejudice to claim the books aren’t “crime fiction”. But they definitely do fall at the literary end of the crime fiction spectrum, with themes for each book and thematic explorations of ethics and morality running throughout the series.
With characters who grow and change over the course of the series; the author’s fondness for word play and her often poetic language; and the rigorous intellectual, philosophical, moral, and cultured scaffolding every story is mounted on, these books will probably not appeal to readers looking for a straightforward murder mystery.
I’ve tried before on this blog to come up with a list of authors to try if you like Louise Penny, and I still think Jane Langton’s Homer and Mary Kelly mysteries are the closest match for style. But here is a list of other books that might hit the spot while fans of Louise Penny-style literary crime fiction (Shhh, don’t tell the author I said crime fiction!) wait for next year’s Armand Gamache book.
(I’ve listened to all of the Armand Gamache books on audio, as I do most of my crime fiction, so all of the books on this list are also recommended as audiobooks.)
Jasper Fforde
Thursday Next series
Less serious and with fantasy elements, the word play and humor of these books might appeal to readers who find the banter of the residents of Three Pines one of the best parts of this series.
Jane Langton
Homer and Mary Kelly series
The author imbues her mysteries with history and culture with deftness and humor. The marriage of Homer and Mary Kelly is reminiscent of the Armand and Rene Marie Gamache partnership.
G.M. Malliet
Max Tudor series
Classic village mysteries with a handsome, unmarried vicar in the lead role, these stories have the wit and ironic self-regard seen in the lighter books in the Armand Gamache series.
Inger Ash Wolfe
Hazel Micallef series
Darker in tone than even the darkest of the Armand Gamache books, the Hazel Micallef books may appeal to readers looking for literary crime fiction with realistic characters set in Canada.
So good to hear that the latest Gamache is up to standard of the previous ones. I agree with you that it is crime fiction but with a level of thoughtfulness that you don’t often get in those kinds of novels.
I have only read the first three in Louise Penny’s series, I think it will take me a while to get to this one. I have read some of each of the series you mentioned except for the Max Tudor series and I do have Wicked Autumn, which I should read this fall. Thanks for the reminder.
Hi Laurie
What about Tana French?
Karen
I almost included her in my list, but changed my mind at the last minute. I should add her for the complex characters, probably. Thanks!
My mom loves the Homer and Mary Kelly books. You’re the only blogger I’ve ever seen mention them
I’m probably as old as your mom, then (55?)! I’ve never been a mystery reader but I remembered loving Jane Langton’s children’s books (especially The Diamond in the Window) and when I saw she had adult books I read them all, even though they were mysteries!
https://www.mysteryscenemag.com/blog-article/2564-laurie-r-king-on-jane-langtons-the-diamond-in-the-window
Listening to Pagan Winter by G.M. Malliett now, and feeling I should have waited till November or December, which is the time period of the events in the book, but it’s still good!
Your comments were going into spam and I almost missed them! I think the extra musing and philosophizing that makes people love Louise Penny books drives some mystery readers crazy, but it’s what makes them so good for readers who want more than just a mystery!